Why Tariffs Are Essential to Protect Western Democracies and Address the Trade Deficit

Donald Trump began his second presidency with determination. Now that the midterm elections are behind us, it is time to take stock. His tariffs have had economic and political consequences worldwide. But what do they mean for Western democracies and their growing trade deficit? The most important lesson is clear: tariffs are an excellent economic and strategic weapon, provided they are used against the right countries.

Trump Addresses Two Fundamental Problems
Already during his first presidency, Trump was frustrated by two issues: the enormous American trade deficit and allies who benefited from American military power without paying for it. His plans were disrupted by the coronavirus pandemic, after which Biden took over the presidency and introduced unprecedented woke and immigration policies.
American voters rejected those policies and handed Trump an overwhelming election victory. With Republican majorities in Congress and a conservative Supreme Court, he was able to implement his policies decisively.
Trump chose two measures: allies finally had to pay for their own defense, and almost all countries were subjected to import tariffs. The level of these tariffs was largely determined by the American trade deficit with the country concerned.
This created three categories: dictatorial manufacturing countries such as China, emerging economies functioning as raw material exporters, production locations, or transit countries, and wealthy Western democracies. The latter category should instead have been treated as economic and strategic partners.
China: Why Tariffs Are Necessary
China provides the clearest example of why tariffs work.
The Chinese dictatorship keeps its currency artificially cheap, restricts capital flows, and uses state-owned enterprises to acquire foreign companies and technology. Thanks to an undervalued currency and extremely cheap (slave) labour, China can continue exporting at very low prices indefinitely.
Chinese workers earn hardly anything, while Western multinationals make enormous profits. Apple, for example, has iPhones manufactured cheaply in China and sells them worldwide at high prices. The profits are then transferred through international tax structures to offshore locations such as the Cayman Islands and the Bahamas.
Those billions do not return to the United States and therefore do not directly benefit American manufacturing capacity or resolve the trade deficit.
Trump wanted to put an end to this. American companies had to invest in their own country again, relocate production away from China, and repatriate their foreign profits. A tax holiday for repatriated profits and lower corporate taxes was intended to encourage this.
High tariffs are entirely justified against a dictatorship that economically exploits its own population, floods foreign markets, and acquires Western technology.
Western democracies do not have to allow their own industries to be destroyed by a communist dictatorship that does not follow the same rules. (Under President Clinton, China joined the WTO with the promise that it would comply with WTO rules.)
Vietnam and Mexico: China's Back Door
Trump understood that tariffs on China alone were insufficient. Chinese companies use other countries to circumvent American trade restrictions.
Vietnam became an important production location and transit hub for Chinese goods. Products that actually originated in China subsequently reached America under a Vietnamese label.
Mexico played a similar role. Thanks to the North American Free Trade Agreement, Chinese companies could serve the American market through Mexico without facing the same trade barriers.
Trump responded with high tariffs and threatened to reopen existing trade agreements. Mexico had to commit to closing Chinese backdoor routes.
This is where his approach proves its value. There is no point in taking economic action against a dictatorship if it can still export without restrictions through a neighbouring country.
The American trade deficit can only be addressed structurally when such back doors are closed.
Canada: Where Trump Went Completely Wrong
With Canada, however, Trump made a disastrous mistake.
Canada had for years taken a naive approach toward Chinese investment, migration, and economic influence. A tougher Canadian stance toward China was therefore justified.
But Trump went much further. He repeatedly referred to the Canadian prime minister as a governor, spoke about annexation, and encouraged separatist sentiments in oil-rich Alberta.
In doing so, he turned a necessary economic discussion into the humiliation of a friendly democracy.
The consequences were particularly disastrous around the Great Lakes and New England. The industries of Ontario, Michigan, and other American states are completely interconnected. Automotive parts cross the border several times during the production process.
Tariffs on Canadian goods therefore directly affect American businesses, workers, and consumers.
Canada is not China. It is a wealthy democracy with decent working conditions, comparable economic standards, and deeply integrated industries.
By attacking Canada economically, Trump damaged his own economy and his most important ally.
The political consequences were equally significant. Canada finally seemed ready to move on from the Liberals, who had allowed the country's economy to stagnate after ten years of woke, climate, and lockdown policies.
Conservative Pierre Poilievre appeared to be the likely winner, but Trump's hostile behaviour gave Mark Carney and the Liberals an unexpected lifeline.
Even conservative Canadians wanted nothing more to do with Trump or Trumpism in Canada.
Sentiment also shifted in the American industrial states. The economically integrated border regions, which are largely swing states, moved toward the Democrats, with serious political consequences during the midterm elections.
The conclusion is unavoidable: tariffs against friendly Western democracies are economically damaging and politically self-destructive.
Europe: Decades of Free American Protection
Europe is a different story.
Since the fall of the Berlin Wall, American presidents have demanded that European NATO countries spend more on their defense. Meanwhile, Europe continued benefiting from American military protection without making a proportionate contribution.
Trump had already raised this issue during his first presidency. European leaders laughed at him and thought they had finally gotten rid of him when he left office.
When Russia invaded Ukraine under Biden, it became clear how disastrous that attitude had been.
Europe had hardly any operational armies, ammunition stockpiles, weapons, or sufficient defense industry. At the same time, it had made its energy supply dependent on dictatorial regimes, particularly Russia.
The Netherlands stopped gas production, Germany and Belgium closed a total of 41 nuclear power plants (only three new ones opened in Europe), and Europe imported massive amounts of energy from Norway, the United States, Russia, and Qatar.
This combination of woke and climate-caliphate policies made Europe economically, militarily, and strategically extremely vulnerable.
The greatest political responsibility lies with Angela Merkel.
Merkel and the Destruction of German Industry
During Merkel's 16 years in power, Germany, Europe's largest economy, experienced sixteen years of stagnation and economic decline. Nuclear energy was phased out, dependence on Russia and China increased enormously, defense was completely neglected (Minister Ursula von der Leyen), and millions of low-skilled Muslim immigrants, some of them terrorists, were admitted.
Structural reforms or modernization of the economy were completely absent in every respect.
Germany became a bureaucratic, poorly digitalized country with outdated infrastructure and an industrial sector that found it increasingly difficult to compete internationally.
The German business model was simple: export high-quality cars and machinery to China and the United States, while cheap Russian energy and American defense protection kept costs low.
China has now copied German technology and produces cheaper, often better cars and machinery itself. At the same time, the Chinese market is becoming increasingly difficult for foreign manufacturers to access because China's government policy is to acquire knowledge through mandatory partnerships, copy it, and then close its domestic market to foreign companies.
With his tariffs, Trump also put an end to guaranteed access to the American consumer market.
German industry is now confronted with enormously high energy costs and energy shortages, Chinese competition, and American trade barriers.
Europe's trade deficit with China, which has now reached €1 billion per day, and deindustrialization resulting from energy and climate policies, which are causing a sharp decline in competitiveness, demonstrate just how vulnerable this export model, and therefore Europe itself, has become.
Europe must finally put the prosperity and purchasing power of its own citizens first.
VAT: Europe's Forgotten Trade Barrier
Another major source of American frustration is European VAT.
America does not have a nationwide VAT system like Europe. American sales tax varies by state and county, ranging from 0% (Nevada) to 10.13% (Louisiana), and does not apply to services, only to goods. Reducing taxes for American businesses and citizens by the same amount as the tariffs the United States imposes on other countries is a smarter way of levying taxes and effectively works like imposing VAT on other countries instead of on your own citizens.
European companies can sell their products for export without European VAT. American companies, on the other hand, face high European VAT rates when selling to European consumers.
This makes the American market attractive to European exporters, while European consumers are heavily taxed by their own governments.
The EU thereby encourages exports rather than domestic consumption.
High VAT is an enormous obstacle to consumer spending and therefore prosperity. On top of that, there are also European import duties on American products.
Europe should reform its own tax policies instead of remaining exclusively dependent on foreign markets and complaining about Trump's tariffs.
Tariffs as a Geopolitical Instrument of Power
The most important conclusion is that tariffs are not going to disappear, not even under the Democrats. Tariffs are a very powerful instrument through which Western democracies can defend their economic interests, security, and political independence.
But a clear distinction must be made between friends and enemies. Friendly countries deserve almost complete free trade. Europe should seek balanced, reciprocal trade agreements with the United States. Economic action should instead be taken against countries that undermine European interests. Take Turkey and Morocco, with their refugee and migrant flows used as Hybrid Tactics against Europe. Europe continues to provide financial support to these countries, even though they do not cooperate sufficiently on crucial matters affecting European interests.
Why should European taxpayers finance undemocratic regimes that use migration as a means of pressure, exert foreign political influence, or threaten European allies? EU can install extremely high tariffs when Turkey threatens Greece or Cyprus, sends migrants toward Europe, or finances unwanted political activities through religious and educational institutions in Europe.
The same applies to Morocco failing to cooperate on migration issues. We all remember the orchestrated invasion of Ceuta, and the blackmail that Europe is under.
These two countries are economically dependent on the European market. Therefore, Europe possesses an enormous position of power that it does not use.
China, a dictatorship, should also face direct economic consequences. Think of all the atrocities that are happening in China: forced labour among Uyghurs, dumping of subsidized products, excluding European companies out of their markets. Europe should act and impose heavy trade tariffs.
Tariffs can be reduced once the conditions are improved. That is far more effective than endless diplomatic discussions and non-binding declarations.
Protect Our Prosperity and Democracies
The EU must introduce a clear system: zero percent tariffs for reliable partners, reciprocal tariffs for equal trading partners, and extremely high tariffs for countries that harm our interests. If necessary, 200 percent. Those who do not comply with our conditions lose access to our consumer market.
Together, Western democracies possess the wealthiest consumer markets in the world. That is our greatest source of economic power.
The American trade deficit shows what happens when that power is insufficiently used for years. At the same time, Canada proves that a trade weapon aimed at the wrong target can damage one's own economy.
Trump's lesson is therefore crystal clear: protect your allies, punish economic enemies, and use access to our market as an instrument of power.
Tariffs are not an end in themselves. They are the perfect instrument for defending our prosperity, industry, security, and democratic independence.
But only when we finally learn to use them against the right countries.
Image credits: Ian Mikraz via Unsplash.



